Karanikolaou and The Bachelorette alum Tyler Cameron reportedly had a fling in November 2019. In December, a source told People that the romance had fizzled out, but then in January 2020, they were spotted together in Miami, Florida celebrating the new year with friends on a yacht.
Apparently, things weren’t serious between them because, in June 2020, she was caught in a flirty exchange with To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before star Noah Centineo on Instagram. In October, the two were photographed by paparazzi packing on the PDA at a Halloween party. That relationship didn’t last, either, and she doesn’t seem to be dating anyone at the moment.