Hilariously relatable, Kevin accused Amanda of calling a friend’s baby cute, even if she truly believes it’s not. And without hesitation, James correctly responds, “Oh, she guilty. She guilty as hell.”
Amanda’s final accusation is the most scandalous, as Kevin accuses the former The Real co-host of making a homemade sex tape. “Guilty or not guilty, Amanda?” he asks.
Before she can hold up her sign, James blurts out his response: “Guilty.” As the group breaks out into shocked laughter, Amanda clarifies that it was “only one time.”
Check out the full clip above, and tune in Tuesdays on E! to see celebs like Keke Palmer, Julie Bowen, Jimmy Kimmel, DJ Khaled and more go head-to-head.
Celebrity Game Face season three premieres tonight, June 21, at 9 p.m. on E!.