I Care a Lot is a black comedy/thriller about a professional guardian in the US.
Marla Grayson runs a lucrative, well-oiled racket, convincing the courts to grant her guardianship over dozens of elderly people whom she places in nursing homes. There they are sedated and left unable to contact anyone in the outside world. She then sells off their homes and assets, all through dubious but legal means, and pockets the proceeds.
Anyone who watched last Monday’s Four Corners episode State Control, would recognise some shocking similarities between our 45-minute investigation and the Golden Globe winning movie.
The difference being that, in Australia, it’s not individuals exploiting people with dementia, brain injuries and other disabilities — it’s our own state governments.
For those who didn’t catch it, a brief rundown:
An epic plot twist
There is an element in the Australian system that would truly “up the stakes” for a movie plot. That is, the gag laws by the states which stop these “wards of the state” (or “customers” as the Queensland Public Trustee officially calls them) from speaking out publicly.
Laws in every state and territory (except for the ACT) stop the media from identifying these people — even after they have died. The penalties: tens of thousands of dollars and/or six months in jail or more. Hence, the ABC’s applications to two Supreme Courts to lift the ban and tell these stories.
Do you have a story to share about the Public Trustee system?
Email us at [email protected] or for confidential tips visit here.
And now for the plot twist.
If someone under the control of the Queensland’s Public Trustee office wants to hire a lawyer to go to court to argue for a release, the office can refuse and withhold their own money. If someone else — a family member or friend — stumps up to pay the legal costs, the Public Trustee office will then use that person’s own funds to fight the application
It means that a tiny handful of people ever escape these orders. The rest spend their lives having their money, assets and lives controlled by a faceless state government bureaucracy with no recourse.
Space to play or pause, M to mute, left and right arrows to seek, up and down arrows for volume.WatchDuration: 43 minutes 56 seconds43m State Control: Australians trapped, stripped of assets and silenced.
It could happen to you
For anyone who thinks these stories are an aberration, here’s a taste of the hundreds of emails I’ve received since the program aired, from around the country:
For anyone who thinks this is a problem that could never touch you, think again. The people writing to me are concerned family members looking after the elderly or someone with a disability, someone who had a stroke, someone with an internal family dispute and sometimes people who thought accessing a free will was a good idea.
Will reviews see any fixes?
The day after the program aired, Queensland’s Attorney-General Shannon Fentiman spoke in Parliament, describing it as “difficult to watch” and “uncomfortable viewing”.
She announced two reviews — one external and one run by the Queensland Public Trustee office itself.
Her statement described the “allegations” on Four Corners as highlighting “a number of damaging past practices by the Public Trustee stretching back decades”. That’s not true. Two of them relate to 2020 and 2021.
ABC News Daily
‘Like being kidnapped’: Australia’s guardianship victims
ABC reporter Anne Connolly on the Australians who’ve been virtually abducted by the state, stripped of their money and silenced.
Space to play or pause, M to mute, left and right arrows to seek, up and down arrows for volume.
She also said these practices no longer occur under Queensland’s current leadership of the Public Trustee office. However, two of the people featured in the Four Corners program had their experiences in 2020 and 2021 which is when the new leadership was in place.
Perhaps just as disturbing as the actions of the offices of the Queensland Public Guardian and Public Trustees is the lack of action by the organisations that are supposed to protect people: the Queensland Human Rights Commission and the Queensland Ombudsman.
As one person wrote back after the ABC replied to her email:
“Thank you so much. This has seriously made my year. This is the furthest I’ve gotten in two years of advocating. I continually hit brick walls.”
The villain in I Care a Lot is an attractive blonde woman in a tailored suit with perfect hair. In Australia, there’s no face to our guardian and trustee system. In fact, we can’t even give a face to the victim without risking a hefty fine or a jail sentence. Now that seems like another far-fetched Hollywood storyline except it’s our law.